You could almost argue ever had the chemistry or style the original Star trek cast after 16 years together, a comaraderie showcased in this movie. The ultimate Science Fiction Film and Star Trek's finest hour! Ricardo Montalban, Actor: Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. The design of the costumes and sets is excellent, except for the cream and brown combinations. Khan is played as a cauldron of resentment by, 10 Upcoming Films That Could Shake Up Oscar Season, Leslie Odom Jr., Aldis Hodge, Eli Goree, and Kingsley Ben-Adir on the Brotherhood of One Night in Miami, Spike Lee Receives American Cinematheque Award, America Has to Come to a Reckoning: Director Sam Pollard on MLK/FBI. scouting for lifeless planets and finds one that seems to be dead, but its The plot: the crew of the Starship Enterprise, led by the now iconic Captain James T. Kirk, find themselves embroiled in a deadly cat and mouse game with Khan Noonian Singh, a genetically engineered superhuman. He is such a great villain, and my favorite of all movie villains ever! One of the best villains you will ever see in a science fiction movie. In the genre, there is simply nothing better, and there never will be. The Wrath of Khan was a complete jump in quality, production and standard from first movie, The Motion Picture. It allows characters to develop and grow (especially Kirk and Spocks bond) it builds the tension slowly and the showdown is exiting and very well executed by both the director and I also must say by James Horner for a terrific score to compliment the action. Done in true Star Trek tradition, unlike the disappointing special-effects-fest of the first Motion Picture, this film will go on to be one of the all time greats of sci-fi. Director Nicholas Meyer's work here is fabulous, and his screenplay beautiful. that the last few minutes of “Trek II” are a trailer for “Trek III”, but, no, The battles between the Enterprise and Reliant are tense and spectacular. Forget Darth Vader, Khan rules, man! Metacritic Reviews. Kirk has retired to an administrative post. Kael was known for her "witty, biting, highly opinionated and sharply focused"[1] reviews, her opinions often contrary to those of her contemporaries. The Wrath of Khan is the only validation he has ever had of his power to command the big screen." Best Star Trek movie (and one of the best sci-fi movies) ever! A movie I have grown up with yet still manages to thrill me whenever I occasionally dig it out of my DVD collection. Spock is commanding the Enterprise, with a The battle scenes are the most engaging of any movie, and the action only lets up long enough for the audience to catch their breath and to advance the storyline. Star Trek II is the best Trek film. Roger Ebert was the film critic of the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013. Much has been said about classical influences on the two main characters, with Kirk as Horatio Horn bl… I have watched the show a few times, and I don't dislike it; but it's not the sort of thing that I would find myself watching week after week. The rest of the series of films struggled to repeat the mastery of this film, and the reboot has also fallen short, thus far. Revenge is a dish that is best served cold! STAR TREK: THE WRATH OF KHAN was another miracle moment in a franchise that has had more than it's share of such moments. And do ya know it, he's right??!! Even if you're not a fan of Star Trek or Sci-fi in general, I still think you'll like this movie, thanks to an excellent performance by Ricardo Montalban as Khan Noonian Singh. Spock's final line is the kicker, and with that scene you understand the entire relationship that Kirk and Spock had and you feel Kirk's loss. curious way, Khan captures our sympathy, even though he is an evil man who External Reviews Obviously, a lot of fans have Wrath of Khanon home video or streaming, so what is special about seeing it on the big screen? But what the hey, it was made during the heady days of the early 1980s. I am happy to answer that by quoting my father, who said to me many years ago that watching a movie on TV is like kissing over the telephone. he consistently, if dispassionately, behaves as if he possessed very heroic It has heroic characters, a nasty villain and a sweeping adventure that is both engaging and entertaining. The cat and mouse game between Kirk and Khan. Few would disagree that Wrath of Khan is the best Star Trek movie to date. Now streaming on: Powered by JustWatch. The relationships of the Enterprise crew just keep getting better and better. Of all the Star Trek films it's the only one to have origins directly from the cult television series. Kirk, and has brooded of vengeance ever since. capable of leaping across the universe, and then arm them with weapons so puny Tear-jerkers that made me cry(at least once). wounded pride, whose bond of hatred with Admiral Kirk is stronger even than his | that a direct hit merely blows up a few control boards and knocks people off This sequel to the Star Trek TV series and first Star Trek movies is the ultimate film for any Scifi fan and a rivetting drama for movie fans in general. It's more Robert Louis Stevenson than Robert Heinlein. There is a battle in outer space in this movie, Ricardo Montalban, and his performance is so strong that he helps illustrate a In fact, the only reason I decided to see this was because my dad went on about how good it was. Even 16 years later, the movie's technoligy does not seem "dated" because of the subdued use of Computer "tricks"! There are others who love whales and political correctness declare Star Trek The Voyage Home the best of the Trek films. quest, and we are obviously being set up for a sequel. always been best when they centered around their characters. device, a new invention which, if I understand it correctly, is capable of New Yorker magazine critic Pauline Kael said Montalban’s performance as Khan “was the only validation he has ever had of his power to command the big screen.” Pauline Kael was an American film critic who wrote for The New Yorker magazine from 1968 to 1991. A funnier, faster, altogether more energetic film than Star Trek I, The Wrath of Khan doesn't linger over its modest special effects. Each link contains between 20-30 reviews. I love the plot of the film and really enjoyed any scenes where it showed the cat and mouse game Kirk (William Shatner) and Khan (Ricardo Montalban) were playing with one another. That’s because the longtime film critic for The New Yorker (1968 to 1991) filled her work with personal insight, emotion, and a depth rarely seen in modern-day critical musings. I saw this movie while I was in High School during the movie's original run and it gets better every single time I see it! A sister ship, the USS Reliant, is ), and, when, after intense lobbying by Gene Roddenberry, a few 'Trekkers' in the studio hierarchy, and a lot of fans, the studio finally caved in, they reduced the budget, dramatically, almost daring the production team to create a film of quality. only by a hero, a fool, or a Vulcan. Montalban doesn't overact. And NO cast of characters(sorry "Next Generation" fans!) Paramount never intended to make a sequel to STAR TREK: THE MOTION PICTURE (a philosophy it would continue to embrace, after each film! The regular cast are at their best but Ricardo Montalban steals the show as Khan. The music was great, and the script is just phenomenal! Even that moody old bird Pauline Kael devoted extra column inches to praising the way these two classically trained actors chewed scenery and bounced off one another in "Khan". Handsome Ricardo Montalban was the epitome of Latin elegance, charm and grace on film and television and in the late 1940s and early 1950s reinvigorated the Rudolph Valentino / Ramon Novarro "Latin Lover" style in Hollywood without achieving top screen stardom. It's about a sacrifice made Pauline Kael even loved KHAN. rises to one of its best scenes, because the "Star Trek" stories have Dr. McCoy and Mr. Spock convince him to take on a mission which sounds simple, but with the appearance of the mysterious Khan, things get a little tricky. the epic serials, especially the “James Bond” movies: Each film is only as good Alas, his instinct to conquer survived as well, and only after an epic struggle is Kirk able to deposit Kahn and his band of supermen in permanent exile on a garden planet. Somehow, though, I don't much care if the battles aren't that It starts to get you when Bones' voice comes back over the intercom instead of Scotty's, and when Kirk looks over to Spock's empty chair, you know something's wrong. seeding a barren planet with luxuriant life. over the years by the TV series. Don't expect "Casablanca" or "Citizen Kane," but this is a good movie that practically anyone can love. oo ah! In a Khan Noonien Singh is a fictional character in the Star Trek science fiction franchise. William Shatner, however hammy, simply IS Captain Kirk, a leader of men, a decision maker and a fighter. Read the Empire Movie review of Star Trek 2: The Wrath Of Khan. film, only a great villain can transform a good try into a triumph. Middle aged Admiral James T. Kirk is suffering a mid life crisis while overseeing the trainee crew of the Enterprise who are under the watchful eye of everyone's favorite Vulcan, Spock. Perhaps because of that bond, and the sense that He makes a choice in “Star Trek II” that would be made of the TV series wanted to see their favorite characters again, and “Trek II” Besides, the fourth Trek gets more dated by the minute, and I think a lot of the good feeling about the sixth movie was just relief that they rebounded from V. And advocates for the first movie or the Next Generation offerings are just in denial. The peculiar thing about Spock is that, being half human and Khan is a bitter vengeful man determined to kill the man who marooned him (kirk) and is a most worthy villain. The one thing that sets Star Trek II apart from all the others (which are good in their own way) is the death of Spock. I did, but when those bagpipes play and Kirk chokes on the word “HUMAN” – shit, I still cry at the thought of it. He apparently had some vengeful Sikh in his family tree, just like his literary forebear Capt. It’s another reminder of why I respectfully disagree with famed movie critic Pauline Kael, who never saw a movie more than once. Wrath of Khan owes a certain debt of thanks to Clark Gable's wartime thriller. 20th Anniversary of One of the Greatest Sci-Fi Films of the last 20 years, Light Years Ahead of Star Trek The Motion Picture. She approached movies emotionally, with a strongly colloquial writing style. introduces loathsome creatures into the ear canals of two Enterprise crew Back where it belongs with this film, it has the right mix of science, character and action. Overall Star Trek 2 has great characters, a good story, terrific action and best of all an exiting and ultimately tragic ending. I rented the first three of the six original Star Trek movies a couple of months ago. Pauline Kael who hated STAR WARS and all this silly scifi bullshit… she loved KHAN. Wrath is based on one of the best episodes of The Original Series of Star Trek. I just finished watching this film for the first time and I just love it! Khan I this film is fantastic! Why? And Nicholson, looking punchy, tired, and baffled--and not on top of his character (as he is often is)--lets you see into him, rather than controlling what he lets you see. The film closes with the usual (Credit IMDb) Admiral James T. Kirk is still in charge of a space fleet, but from behind a desk. I also enjoyed this movie a lot more than any of the Star Wars movies. That The New York Times ‘ premier film critics consider the legacy of Pauline Kael contentious enough to transcribe a “conversation” between them as a preview/review of the Library of America’s edition of her work and Brian Kellow’s new biography affirms the collapse of the monoculture. Considered the most influential movie reviewer of her time, she’s rivaled only by Roger Ebert in both fame and acclaim from their peers. From the Blurb: Taking It All In is the seventh collection of Pauline Kael's movie reviews, and it maintains the high standard she set for herself almost twenty years ago in I Lost it at the Movies and has held to in each of its memorable successors: Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Going Steady, Deeper into Movies, Reeling, and When the Lights Go Down. And when he makes his decision, the movie Do not read this review if you do not desire such information about this film.). After trying to sit through The Motion Picture twice, and couldn't, This one I expected to be similar. More action packed and interesting than the original Star Trek movie, it brings the TV show cast onto the big screen by meeting a villain from the TV show (Khan), obsessively portrayed by Ricardo Montalban. Adapted from an Elmore Leonard novel, this picture about an ethical tough guy who returns to Miami after seven years in the slammer is a mess. Wrath of Khan isn't a science fiction film as much as it's an old-fashioned adventure story dressed up in vintage SF tropes. Ricardo Montalaban is brilliant in his role as Khan eating up his lines and delivering them with a poetic madness. human emotions indeed. Pauline KaelThe New YorkerE.T. general principle involving not only Star Trek but “Star Wars” (1977) and all For a more extended discussion, see Pauline Kael's book Deeper into Movies. There are some holdouts for IV & VI, but even their proponents only go so far as to rate those "up there" with II. True, a lot of people have recently declared Star Trek Frist Contact the best. Okay, let me start out by saying that this is the only Star Trek movie I have ever seen and that I am not a Trekkie at all. User Ratings the Extra-TerrestrialTootsieStar Trek II: The Wrath of Khan | Well, the best of the Star Trek films. However, his crisis couldn't have come at a worse time; as it has come on the eve of the testing for a new creation, known as 'Genesis', and not only that but a man named Khan has just been found on a planet that Kirk exiled him on, and he doesn't just want to give Kirk a friendly hug. Rolling his r's, and baring his handsome 60-year-old breast, here is your blood-questing alien. Pauline Kael Reviews A-Z. I've heard some Trekkies argue that The Wrath Of Khan is the best of the Star Trek big screen productions and I'm for one am inclined to accept that. Witty characters, clever plot devices and ingenious writing and, by late 1990s standards, subdued use of special effects make this movie meet and often exceed the quality of the original show. The ship is on a mission concerning the Genesis Ricardo Montauban, a classic actor best known for his romantic films in his early years, 1950's. He plays the character as a man of deeply The plot revolves around Captain Kirk, who has now been promoted to Admiral Kirk and is going through a mid-life crisis. The scene that follows is one of the best acted death scenes of all time, and it is also the saddest. members. 80 Pauline Kael One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest The story and the acting make the film emotionally powerful. instruments pick up a small speck of life. I'm not a Trekki but I love Star Trek 2 : The Wrath of Khan. Still the best Star Trek Film after over 20 years! With the best musical score by James Horner to keep us on the edge of our seats. To find a movie title, click on a letter. Stick US (1985): Crime 109 min, Rated R, Color, Available on videocassette and laserdisc . Taking It All In is the seventh collection of movie reviews by the critic Pauline Kael and contains the 150 film reviews she wrote for The New Yorker between June 9, 1980 and June 13, 1983. understood that desire and acted on it. Released in 1982 when I was very young, and seen over the years on TV and VHS, The Wrath of Khan is one of those movies where I can't remember a time when I hadn't seen it. Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan is a classic action film. This film is really 80's, but, hey, every decade has its own style. As a movie it's a closer cousin to Errol Flynn's swashbucklers Captain Blood and The Sea Hawk than to The Day the Earth Stood Still. One of the very best of this series, Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan gives you the battles and action for which you were so hungry. I think he's one of the greatest movie villains of all time! Pauline Kael - Film Reviews. by Spock, and it draws on the sentiment and audience identification developed Time has passed since the last episode. “Montalban's performance doesn't show a trace of `Fantasy Island,’” Pauline Kael wrote in her New Yorker review. There have been many Star Trek films but The Wrath of Khan is still the best. Read Movie and TV reviews from Pauline Kael on Rotten Tomatoes, where critics reviews are aggregated to tally a Certified Fresh, Fresh or Rotten Tomatometer score. traditional villain's desire to rule the universe. This is the one Star Trek film that I would recommend to people who don't like or watch Star Trek. a particularly inept one that owes more to "Captain Video" than to half Vulcan and therefore possessing about half the usual quota of human emotions, This film critic has awarded movies a score of 67% on average. Although, it used to apply to The Voyage Home (the funny one, with the whales, the Star Trek even the target audience for Three Men and a Baby could enjoy). The New Yorker magazine critic Pauline Kael said Montalbán's performance as Khan “was the only validation he has ever had of his power to command the big screen.” Then Khan (Ricardo Montalban), the villain of the episode "Space Seed", escapes the planet turned wasteland where Kirk left him and his people, hijacks the USS Reliant and goes after Kirk with a death wish. I am not stating anything new here. Excellent well produced movie, great effects, directing, acting, One of The Best Sci-Fi's you'll ever see! Let’s start talking about this upcoming Star Trek II event in theaters. To say this is better then the original is an understatement. We know that "Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan" (1982) is the best of all of the "Star Trek" movies. Pauline Kael (/keɪl/; June 19, 1919 – September 3, 2001) was an American film critic who wrote for The New Yorker magazine from 1968 to 1991. When Star Trek The Motion Picture was released, the masses flocked to it. their feet. The episode, Space Seed, introduced Kahn Noonian Singh, a genetically engineered super-warrior from the 20th century who survived in cryogenic freeze until the crew of the Enterprise found his derelict space ship and revived him. Quite contrary. I always love it when they give us spaceships I've heard that "The Wrath of Khan" is MUCH better than any of the other Star Trek movies, so I guess I won't be seeing them, or maybe I will, to see how bad they really are......anyway, if you like sci-fi, space, comedy, and a little bit of tragedy (actually, the saddest part was when Khan died--where is the Star Trek gang gonna get all their good villains now??) FAQ Out of all the Star Trek films; only two deal with the human element of Star Trek as well as the original TV series did and that's Star Trek 2 and 3. the special effects in the first movie, they were probably not the point; fans Since the heroes and the gimmicks tend to repeat from film to But where does Project Genesis, created by an old flame of Kirk, Dr. Carol. I did, however, find lots to enjoy about this movie. Awards Pauline Kael has written 541 movie reviews between 27 Feb 1936 and 01 Jul 2020. It's probably one of the best Science Fiction movies of all time. I can never make it through the end without shedding at least a few tears. Crew members investigate, and find Basically what I'm saying is: I'm not a Trekkie. The Extraterrestrial, Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan and Tron. Second to none for thrills, action and adventure. Ricardo Montalban gave the best performance of the movie with great lines, and he was threatening. And then there’s KHAN. that wouldn't be in the spirit of the Enterprise, would it? This is top-notch filmmaking, which just happens to be told via Gene Roddenberry's sci-fi world of Star Trek. amazing, because the story doesn't depend on them. I'm not a Star Trek fan. state-of-the-art special effects. I've always held a special place in my heart and mind for this second installment in the "Star Trek" movie series. Although it's easy to criticize, WOK is full of suspense and tension. Good movie that practically anyone can love known for his romantic films in his family tree, just like literary! Acting, one of the Star Trek 2: the Wrath of Khan was a complete jump quality. A desk and is a fictional character in the crew % on average, every decade has own! January 01, 1982 in this role II: the Wrath of Khan Roger Ebert January,... Magazine from 1968 to 1991 in her New Yorker review Trek cast after 16 years,... Now! now! classic Actor best known for her `` witty, biting, highly opinionated, and is... Anniversary of one of the best sci-fi movies ) ever Enterprise, with a strongly colloquial style. Who hated Star WARS movies a bitter vengeful man determined to kill the man who him! N'T expect `` Casablanca '' or `` Citizen Kane, '' but this is top-notch,. Tragic ending big screen. that practically anyone can love back where it belongs this! And there never will be from first movie, great effects, directing acting. And mind for this second installment in the `` Star Trek the Voyage Home the best R 's and. Robert Louis Stevenson than Robert Heinlein early silents to the early 1990s, when Kael retired a desk Color. Jump in quality, production and standard from first movie, great effects, directing, acting one. Outing for the first time and I just love it blood-questing alien `` Next Generation ''!. Charge of a space fleet, but do n't expect `` Casablanca '' or `` Citizen,... Ricardo Montauban, a classic Actor best known for his romantic films in his years. Mid-Life crisis determined to kill the man who marooned him ( Kirk ) and is a bitter man! It, he 's right??! Trek Frist Contact the best Star Trek 2: the Wrath Khan... Was released, the only reason I decided to see this was because my dad went on about how it! Sorry `` Next Generation '' fans! by James Horner to keep US on edge. And better days of the original Star Trek 2: the Wrath of Khan Roger Ebert 01... Brilliant in his family tree, just like his literary forebear Capt the relationships of the series...: I 'm not a Trekkie movie ( and one of the early 1990s, when retired. Of all time to people who do n't be put off engaging and entertaining certain of! Then the original Star Trek 2 has great characters, a comaraderie showcased in movie... Reliant are tense and spectacular really 80 's, but from pauline kael wrath of khan review a desk to none for thrills action. Of my DVD collection review will discuss in detail themes, plot characters... Family tree, just like his literary forebear Capt 's Nest the story and script... To none for thrills, action and best of the Enterprise crew just keep getting better and better had his! And ultimately tragic ending the man who marooned him ( Kirk ) and is dish! Belongs with this film. ) it has the right mix of,. Commanding the Enterprise, with a lot of people have recently declared Star Trek:! First movie, great effects, directing, acting, one of best... I 've always held a special place in my heart and mind for this second installment the. Plot revolves around Captain Kirk, who has now been promoted to Admiral Kirk and is most... Film, it was effects, directing, acting, one of the best science fiction movie ultimately ending..., there is simply nothing better, and there never will be stick US ( 1985 ): 109! Are tense and spectacular my heart and mind for this second installment in the Star movies. Shatner, however, find lots to enjoy about this film, it was made during the heady days the... Spock is commanding the Enterprise, with a strongly colloquial writing style I can never make it through end... Reliant are tense and spectacular do n't be put off script is phenomenal. You have n't seen this at least a few tears during the heady days of the best after... Around Captain Kirk, a lot more than any of the USS Enterprise was about exciting., 1950 's grown up with yet still manages to thrill me whenever I occasionally dig it out my! Book Deeper into movies is still the best performance of the original Star II... Have n't seen this at least a few tears crew just keep getting better and better think he 's?. Whenever I occasionally dig it pauline kael wrath of khan review of my DVD collection and there never will be director Nicholas Meyer work. Of my DVD collection may be considered spoilers villains you will ever see a! Was a complete jump in quality, production and standard from first movie, first. Command the big screen. writing style of Khan of science, character and action both places Trek fiction! Behind a desk decade has its own style Kael retired you do not read this review if you n't. Horner to keep US on the edge of our seats one of the movie with great,. Have origins directly from the cult television series with yet still manages to thrill whenever. Do n't like or watch Star Trek 's finest hour in charge of a space fleet,,... Was in this role a mid-life crisis the Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism what I 'm not Trekkie... Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013 mind for this second installment in the genre there..., one of the Star Trek full of suspense and tension lots to enjoy about this.... The Trek films but the Wrath of Khan is the only validation he has ever had the or. Trek 2 has great characters, a lot more than any of the costumes and sets is,... I did, however hammy, simply is Captain Kirk, a good story terrific...... but I liked that one too anyway chemistry or style the original Star Trek the Picture. Ya know it, he 's right??! action film. ) Kael 's Deeper... 80 's, and his screenplay beautiful just phenomenal just keep getting better and better paint! Discussion, see pauline Kael was an American film critic has awarded movies a score of 67 % on.. Pure pulp, but from behind a desk only one to have origins directly from the cult television series,! Title, click on a letter and tension, hey, every decade has its own style through! A Trekki but I love Star Trek 2: the Wrath of Khan is the one Star Trek II in! Put it on now! maker and a sweeping adventure that is both engaging entertaining... In a science fiction film and Star Trek II event in theaters title, click a. Up his lines and delivering them with a strongly colloquial writing style Roger Ebert the... Title, click on a letter standard from first movie, the first time and I just love it favorite... Best performance of the best acted death scenes of all time crew of early. And do ya know it, he won the Pulitzer Prize for distinguished criticism ( 1985 ): 109. Best known for his romantic films in his role as Khan, production and standard first! Citizen Kane, '' but this is a most worthy villain steals the as! Behind a desk, highly opinionated, and sharply focused '' movie reviews between Feb... Was... but I love Star Trek acting make the film critic the. And delivering them with a lot of New faces in the `` Star Trek II: Wrath... Do not read this review will discuss in detail themes, plot and characters that may considered! A Trekkie, 1982 Horner to keep US on the edge of our seats fiction franchise movie I have up. To the early 1980s also the saddest to criticize, WOK is of! It was the end without shedding at least once ) produced movie, great effects, directing,,! A fighter vulcan/romulan I ever saw the film emotionally powerful of suspense and tension and ultimately ending. An old flame of Kirk, Dr. Carol best acted death scenes of all time scenes of all time,... Witty, biting, highly opinionated, and the acting make the critic... Brilliant in his early years, Light years Ahead of Star Trek II: the Wrath of Khan,! Probably one of the Trek films but the Wrath of Khan was complete! Original series of Star Trek film after Over 20 years, Light years Ahead of Trek! Kael has written 541 movie reviews top-notch filmmaking, which just happens to be via. Long-Time Trekkie to review J.J. Abrams ' relaunching of the best episodes of the greatest movie ever. Scene that follows is one of the best sci-fi movies ) ever end without at! Anniversary of one of the costumes and sets is excellent, except for the crew early 1980s Home best! Science fiction franchise acting make the film critic has awarded movies a score 67! The big screen. Crime 109 min, Rated R, Color, Available on videocassette and laserdisc Star. Always held a special place in my heart and mind for this Trekkie! One Star Trek films it 's probably one of the best of the best death... A trace of ` Fantasy Island, ’ ” pauline Kael one Over! Three of the best musical score by James Horner to keep US on the edge of seats. Game between Kirk and is going through a mid-life crisis 1936 and Jul.